Popular Thanksgiving Pies Pie Chart
NPR asked readers what kind of pie they liked best, and CouponCabin turned pie preferences into a pie chart. A PIE pie chart. I know. INCEPTION. No, wait: pieception? Inpietion? Whatever you call it, someone took America’s dessert opinions and turned them into a graphic that looks ready to be served with a scoop of ice cream. Unfortunately, the people voting made one terrible decision. They picked apple over pumpkin. On Thanksgiving, of all possible occasions. I demand a recount, preferably conducted at the dessert table.
Apple Pie Wins the Popularity Contest
Here’s the historical context: NPR surveyed its online audience during Pie Week in June 2012, rather than polling every household around Thanksgiving. More than 14,000 readers responded to its informal favorite-pie question. Apple came first with 17 percent, followed closely by strawberry-rhubarb at 16 percent and pumpkin at 14 percent. Cherry and blueberry also appeared near the top. Those are the figures NPR reported, and they describe its participating readers, not a scientifically representative national vote. My personal vote still counts double, obviously.
There’s an extra wrinkle in the Thanksgiving graphic. A widely circulated November 2012 CouponCabin pie chart, reproduced by Foodbeast, displayed apple at 20 percent, strawberry at 19 percent, and pumpkin at 16 percent, with several other varieties below them. Those figures aren’t identical to NPR’s published survey percentages. So it’s safer to describe the infographic as a historical graphic inspired by pie-preference coverage, rather than silently treating every number as the same dataset. Confusing? Maybe. But at least every disagreement ends with pie.
But Thanksgiving Means Pumpkin!
Now, about the injustice against pumpkin. I know apple is practically America’s unofficial dessert mascot, and there’s nothing wrong with it. Warm apples, flaky pastry, maybe some cinnamon? Great! But Thanksgiving calls for pumpkin pie. It’s part of the occasion. I don’t care if the family has been arguing over the turkey for three hours; set a pumpkin pie down and suddenly we have common ground. At least until somebody takes the last slice and starts a second argument.
The old post suggested using a rotting jack-o’-lantern from the front stoop as pie filling. Please don’t actually do that. A carved pumpkin left outdoors for weeks is decoration, not dinner. Use suitable food ingredients and a real recipe instead. We can keep the ridiculous joke without sending everybody home with food poisoning. Honestly, one family member getting sick over an experimental dessert is already too many. Grandma doesn’t need to remember Thanksgiving as the year of the emergency bucket.
It’s Pieception, People!
If you want to see the period graphic, the article originally linked to a high-resolution image HERE. That old image needs a rights and live-link check before being republished. And thank you to Elie for tipping Brittany off to this wonderful chart. Friendships built on dessert are the strongest kind. I’m still choosing pumpkin, and I’ll defend that decision with a fork in one hand and a second slice in the other. Happy pieception, everybody.
And if your family refuses to agree on the winner, there’s an obvious solution: serve more than one pie. Apple for the traditionalists, pumpkin for the Thanksgiving loyalists, and something completely unexpected for anybody who wants to start a new argument. That’s a survey result I can support.
Comments 0
No Readers' Pick yet.