How Fly Ash Shortages Are Changing Concrete Production and Material Selection
The most useful by-product of the concrete industry is being lost, and the story being presented in conferences is a cleaner one than that being played out on job sites. Over the years, the fine gray dust trapped from coal power plants and used in concrete has been used for hundreds of thousands of tons in concrete, but with the closing of these plants, it is running low. The generation of coal has also declined significantly over the last decade, and so has the amount of fly ash produced in the U.S.The amount of coal-fired generation has also decreased considerably in the last decade, and consequently, the amount of fly ash generated has also decreased. The vast majority of people will agree on that point.
The rest of the discussion is characterized by comfortable assumptions that never make it off the page into the plant. The following are the ones that need correction.
Why Fly Ash Shortages Are Already Affecting Concrete Producers
The cliff doesn’t move. It has been here for 10 years, and the following slope taking you down is already plotted. The additional capacity will be phased out by 2035, meaning that many of the facilities that are currently shipping ash will already be on a retirement plan.
This is how it’s done on the ground. The precast or ready-mix company receives no notice, a letter, or a phone call. The closest source of supply shuts down. Three states removed is the next closest, and the freight math is not cheesy pozzolanic.
The shortages are increasingly appearing in regions since the mid-2010s, and each new round of retirements means another in some other part of the world. This problem will hit you in the back of the head later, and you will have a pour already planned.
The Challenges of Replacing Fly Ash With Alternative SCMs
Substitution seems easy on a spec sheet, but it is far from simple in a mix design! Fly ash performs multiple functions; it partially replaces the cement, enhances workability, reduces the heat of hydration, and increases the long-term durability. Not all of these supplementary cementitious materials do all of these things and in different proportions.
Each candidate requires its own sets of trial batches, a different admixture tune, and sometimes an alternate modification of the existing mix design that the contractor has already approved. Proper bulk powder handling also matters, as storage conditions can affect material flow and disrupt concrete production. This is where construction materials manufacturing expertise can prove useful as an alternative material is considered, and a formulation that would perform as required is developed.
The Potential and Limitations of Reclaimed Fly Ash
Decades of fly ash have been collected in impoundments and landfills, and the numbers are indeed promising: hundreds of millions of tons, a lot of it chemically identical to the fresh ash used by the industry for decades. It’s a true source of ash harvest, and it’s increasing.
It’s not plug and play. Pond ash is a wet, variable ash that is frequently mixed with bottom ash, soil, or other materials that are in the impoundment. Before ever entering the concrete, someone is required to dry it, screen it, beneficiate it, and prove that it meets ASTM C618.
It involves capital to process the plants close to where they are being harvested, and time. Supply exists. Qualified supply is another number altogether, and it “ramps” slowly.
Why Increasing Cement Content Isn’t Always the Best Solution
The easiest way to do this is to pull the SCM out and increase the amount of Portland cement – and it’s bad in practically every way that counts. Cement, which is the number one carbon source in concrete, is the subject of this study. The higher the amount of clinker, the greater the emissions, and the transition to more clinker is going in the direction opposite to what buyers, specifiers, and regulators are looking for.
It’s also more expensive, produces more heat as it cures (which is an issue in mass pours), and loses some of the longevity that the fly ash was providing to begin with. A spec that starts to get closer to straight Portland cement will be more expensive to pour and more expensive to maintain.
What Slows the Adoption of Alternative Cementitious Materials
The reaction to blame is always pointing at DOT specs, building codes, or EPA’s rules about coal combustion residuals for lack of adoption of alternatives. Specifications do evolve, and that is added friction. The bulk of the delay is upstream of the regulator, however.
The new SCM should be uniform in chemistry, reliable in performance, consistent from season to season and mix to mix, and have a producer who will guarantee delivery at a price the RMC can plan for. Qualification is a process that takes several years; it is not a paperwork process. It’s a list that agencies will update when the data is available. The work, the difficult part, is getting the data there, and the materials-development part of the industry is still getting ready to do it as well.
What Buyers and Specifiers Should Do Now
As fly ash becomes less available, it’s becoming more critical than ever to plan ahead for concrete producers, contractors, and project specifiers. When the original supplier is no longer available, there may not be enough time to qualify an alternate supplier without impacting project schedules.
The buyer should check what their existing sources of fly ash are, what they consider to be a risk of supply, and then discuss other SCM options with their concrete suppliers before shortfalls of fly ash can affect production. Specifiers can assist by considering if material requirements can be met by alternative materials that are also suitably qualified and, if not, determining if it is required to include further performance tests or mix design approvals.
Transitions can be smoother with trial batches, with performance documented and with cooperation and communication between the material suppliers and project teams. The use of reclaimed fly ash and other supplementary cementitious materials could be a viable alternative but will require testing to determine their suitability for each application.
The ingredients vary. Quality doesn’t have to suffer, but more careful choice of materials, earlier testing, and greater collaboration in the supply chain will be needed to maintain quality.
Comments 0
No Readers' Pick yet.